Originally I wasn't going to write anything today- have been feeling really unwell lately and today has been the worst of it. However, I saw today's Extra Credits and was inspired. So, let's all go on a meandering trip through my games collection to see my suggestions to you. Not all of them are recent, and not all of them are porn games, but here it is.
When people talk about the "greats" in the RPG Maker H-Game community, they mostly refer to Overwhored or Harem... but I don't see DL come up too often. Despair Labyrinth is an excellent game combining a pseudo-roguelike kinda feel with game over rape and a morality system. Plus, all the starting characters have very different personalities and playstyles, making for a lot of replayability.
Embric of Wulfhammer's Castle
I don't even know how to describe this... it's a romantic comedy open world puzzle game, I think? There's a crazy amount of depth and things to do here. The ending can potentially go complete off the rails into Gainax territory though, so you've been warned.
If you're into dating sims and visual novels, give this a try. It's a free visual novel/dating sim/board game, if you can believe it, with some fun, quirky characters and the ability to mod the game.
The Crooked Man
I haven't finished playing this one, but it's an excellent RPG Maker-style horror game (I think it's actually created with some other editor....) The game itself dances on that fine line between melancholy and fear... it's an excellent use of your time if you like horror.
Huh, I guess that's it.... If you have any recommendations, put them in the comments.